Towards Better Work: Managers’ and Female Workers’ Perception of Social Upgrading in Foreign-Owned Apparel Factories in Ethiopia
To mitigate youth unemployment and bolster its export-oriented industrialization, Ethiopia attracts foreign direct investment (FDI) to its apparel industry. The employment of low-skilled workers in firms integrated into global value chains (GVC) has brought about a debate regarding whether FDI jobs result in social upgrading for these workers. The existing literature either focuses on one specific labor issue without a holistic analysis of social upgrading or lacks a comparison of workers’ and managers’ understanding of social upgrading. To address this gap, this thesis examines female workers’ and managers’ understanding of social upgrading in foreign-owned apparel factories. This thesis draws on data from 13 managers’ and 11 workers’ interviews and measures social upgrading through the lens of processual and relational well-being. This thesis reveals the conflict between managers’ long-term strategies and female workers’ aspirations for social upgrading, posing a challenge for the Ethiopian government in adapting its public governance to address the ongoing issues. Despite the disadvantaged working conditions, female workers could still use themselves as a labor agency to achieve their ends by starting their businesses. It also shows that managers and workers bring their original countries’ culture into the garment factory, affecting their view on social upgrading. Additionally, the heterogeneity of workers and managers suggests intersectionality is a potential approach to understanding the complexity of social upgrading.
Unsung Heroes or Modern Slaves? The precarity and intersectionality of female migrant domestic workers in Hong Kong during the COVID-19 Pandemic
The breakout of the COVID-19 pandemic dramatically altered societies and the labor market worldwide. Female migrant domestic workers are also disproportionately affected by the pandemic crisis. Migrant domestic workers in Hong Kong have multiple identities as the labor force, migrants, women, and belong to ethnic minorities. Focusing on female migrant domestic workers in Hong Kong, using an intersectionality approach and building on the literature on employment precarity, this study investigates how their multiple identities construct their precarious employment in Hong Kong during the pandemic. A qualitative content analysis in the form of newspaper articles, online journals, as well as NGO reports is therefore conducted within the conceptual frameworks of precariousness in employment and intersectionality. The thesis argues that during the COVID-19 pandemic FMDWs have faced precarity in terms of employment precarity, financial precarity, housing precarity, health precarity, and social precarity due to the intersection of their multiple identities as workers, women, having immigrant status, and belonging to an ethnic minority. As a result of the research, it is recommended that long-term policies for providing necessary and inclusive care to migrant domestic workers be implemented. Furthermore, this thesis advocates for an intersectional approach to measuring the precarity of migrant domestic workers in future research.